Skip to main content

Why so complacent in the high drop out rate?

I had an interview recently at a renowned lab here in India. I admired her work and simply couldn't wait to talk to the PI, tour the lab and telling her that I am a big fan. After the interview, the PI told me about how they are little frugal about lab supplies (and the practice apparently served them well), the 11-12 hour commitment to the lab and their high drop-out rate. All of this was to signify how science-y they are probably. However, I found these practices very uncomfortable. Especially her complacency about the drop-out rate. Indian scientists seem to find a merit in the high drop-out rate from their lab. It is like a badge of honor. Why do you have to assume the reason for them leaving is because you are demanding and/or the student is incompetent? That is stupid.

There are numerous reasons a student can quit working with someone. It doesn't necessarily have to be something wrong about the student!  Why do you have to showcase it like a crown? It doesn't look like it is worth showing off.
This, by no means, implies that the lab needs to "lower their standard" by keeping bad professionals in the lab (bad professionals? or untrained students? - will rant about that in another post). What annoys me is flaunting how people just leave their lab because "not everyone can take it". In fact, a system like this ensures that students in the lab have zero work life balance. You are not really training them to be a professional. You are training them to be a bonded laborer.

I did not get selected for the position. I had decided to not join anyway. Instead, few months later, I joined my current lab at RCB. I like it here. Our guide indulges in a lot of discussion. I have never seen her brag about how we are so exclusive. She does proudly talk about our institute that it has the infrastructure required to do good science. But nothing like that autofellatio.

I am still a fan of her work, not as a student anymore.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Take off-The First Blog

Hello readers! I am starting to write today in a hope that I learn to document everything and weave my words correctly on the advice of a Prof at my Institute. I am a jrf at IMSc, Chennai as of now and work on membrane structure. The work is among the many which land up on the interface of Biology and Physics. I started out to be a Biology student who is now reading Physics. I have named my blog "tishn-a-lab"  which is Urdu for thirst or dryness of lips. It is a very common phrase that you find in poems, mine being from one of Dushyant Kumar's (me gusta el)  ये शफ़क़ शाम हो रही है अब . This title is supposed to convey a couple of things. First, the craving. Being an aspirant for a career in science, you have to always push boundaries of your analytical skills, demand more from the experiment and observation. It never stops. Also, for a larger picture, if you work on one problem, you realize there is so much more that you don't know. YOU HAVE TO GET IT. NO BAIL OUT...

Lest We Forget- Scientists Who Bore The Brunt Of Divisive Politics

Following my rant on scientists being quiet on the unconstitutional Citizenship Amendment Act, here are a few examples from history in a hope to stir their conscience to act now and stop this hegemonic brutality against students and academics. You see, they call it "brain drain" when academics and researchers leave India. I am hoping not lose next Obaid Sidiqqui, APJ Abdul Kalam or Salim Ali as a minion to this ugly and divisive politics and stop this "brain purge" before happening. Dr Abdus Salam: Dr Abdus Salam obtained his PhD in Theoretical Physics from Cambridge in 1950. He returned to his home country of Pakistan in 1951 for a lectureship position. He left Pakistan in 1954 but continued to work with government on vital projects. He finally resigned from his post with Pakistani government when in 1974 a law declaring Ahmadis to be non-Muslims and depriving them of their rights was passed, a religion to which he belonged. He was the first Muslim to...